Look everyone,
We’re all tired. I can’t speak for those on the floors of State Capitols in Wisconsin and Ohio, as I am sure they are more tired than I am; though they continue to fight and stand firm for what they believe in. I’ve never seen Ohio as divided as I ever have since I moved to this state in 1988. The troubling thought is that Ohio can be much further divided than it is now; it almost seems like child’s play compared to what could happen. The attention that Wisconsin has gotten this past week for their version of the public sector union control bill is the only domestic event overshadowing Ohio.
As my bride-to-be and I maintain friendships with various teachers, we have exhausted our sanity levels to convince them that we don’t hate them or their position on Ohio Senate Bill 5; at least as much as they are willing to consider an opposing opinion (ours), which I am thankful for. Understandably, they are very emotional about this issue, since many of their jobs lay on the balance. One close friend of ours has a new house and a baby girl. Another just got his feet off the ground as the lead music director of a high school near Dayton, Ohio. Another friend of ours is in the process of finding herself as she landed upon substitute teaching for elementary school students. Our families are ripe full of teachers or teachers in the making. They all love their jobs, they know what they are doing. All of them can cite various examples of other teachers that are jaded by the system, or don’t care about the well-being of their students as much as receiving their own paychecks, and all of them can give reasons as to why they don’t like their teachers’ union.
As soon as my young lady and I have children, we want the best for them just like any other caring parent does for their children. We want them exposed not only to language arts, science, math, reading, writing; but also to citizenship, government, the arts, astronomy, nature, economics, and much more I’m sure I can’t think of at the moment. The problem is, is that we all very well know our public schools do not provide piano lessons, frequent trips to planetariums, daily walks in the woods, or spontaneous field trips to anywhere history is being made. Our schools have not been able to afford that for all their students, at least at a consistent basis even when economic times were good. As much as various aspects of our learning and culture are vitally important to the upbringing of our children, it just can’t be done.
The thing is – I don’t hate people. I don’t even hate people in unions. What drives me nuts are the emotional appeals to state governments, local clubs, and anyone on Facebook willing to read their side of the story; because they’re barking up the wrong tree. I understand the political advantage to gaining public sympathy, but public sympathy alone does not increase the state budget. Just because we feel a teacher should have every advantage afforded to them for all the hard work they do for our kids does not mean that we can do so. Emotional need and financial ability do not go hand-in-hand; otherwise, everyone in the world would have sufficient food, clothing, and shelter.
Before I go any further, I do want to make some points clear. I do NOT support Ohio SB 5, because 1) The bill is way too cumbersome of a read, chock full of unrelated subjects, and too long to consider seriously. This is crap that Democrats pulled in the U.S. Congress, and Ohio Republicans should not stoop to that level. 2) One of the unrelated subjects is that it defines marriage in Ohio as between a man and a woman. While I fully agree with that idea, that’s not for government to decide. 3) The bill does not exempt firefighters and law enforcement. Firefighters and law enforcement are the only public employees that risk their lives daily just to do their jobs, and they should be last in line for any sort of budget cuts. They’ve earned that right. Just like military, as Ted Nugent would say, this isn’t “public welfare”, this is repayment of a debt we owe to them for what they have given us.
Again – I respect teachers; despite bad apples that occur in every profession, many do one hell of a job. However, they don’t typically go to work wondering if they’ll live to return home that night. Ditto for administrators, superintendents, and any other public employee.
The balance has shifted, and the taxpayers have voted for this change to happen. Governors like Chris Christie (NJ), Scott Walker (WI), and John Kasich (OH) have campaigned on these ideas, so there is no Obama surprise here. We knew this was coming. Just like with any other employer, if the employer has run out of money, or wishes to be more stingy with the money they do have, then that is their right. Such is the message of the taxpayers, the ones who provide the public employees with their salary and benefits in the first place. To be a public employee is to accept that risk. The same goes for any government-funded entity – whether it be non-profit organizations or companies that receive direct corporate welfare in the form of subsidies. If the funds dry up, so do the jobs.
I think we all know this is only the beginning. I do not anticipate this issue letting up in a month or so, and everyone would move on to the next political abomination. This one won’t end. Even if Ohio and Wisconsin pass their laws (however flawed OH SB 5 is), other states will have this battle fought in the near future, and unions will continue to exert their pressure – whether it would be in the press, or the funding of 2012 political campaigns. This isn’t over by any means.
This is also the beginning in that this won’t solve all states’ budget ills. I’m sure state parks, state forests, historical landmarks, and other social programs are next. The states have become the battleground because any government entity that isn’t federal is required by law to balance their budget. The states can’t print money like the feds can.
Another factor that will come into play is Medicaid funding – a federal program whose financial burden is shouldered by the states due to the non-fully funded mandate by the federal government. It also comes with strings attached; you know, “Do as we wish or we’ll cut you off”. I haven’t studied Ohio’s books, but from what I have heard is that Medicaid eats up at least 20% of the State of Ohio’s budget. My gut feeling is that even if the states can fix everything they can within their grasp, they will have to confront the federal government directly. Some states are already doing so in other realms: Arizona and it’s immigration bill, 28 states suing the federal government over the health care bill, Alaska refusing to implement the health care bill, 3 states openly contemplating printing their own currencies (I’d argue the constitutionality of that one), or states flirting with the idea of decriminalizing marijuana trafficking.
We’re witnessing a slow unraveling of American History. We are the history; all of us. As tired as I am fighting for the minds towards what I know is right, somehow I still hold out hope. The only major failure of the Tea Party Movement is that it failed to capture the hearts of all Americans. We hoped for landslides for conservatives that have the courage to reset our country back on our founders’ principles. The best we could get was landslides for the Republican Party. However, the political battles that we are confronting now, and will have to confront for many years ahead – we all have to face regardless of affiliation. Right and wrong will be sorted out. February 2011 will be to many what September 2008 was to many Tea Partiers – when beforehand we may have avoided confrontation and ran away from it, it’s the time when confrontation confronts us, and we have to make a choice. If it hasn’t come to you yet, it will. Wait awhile.